5 Cheese Melt in your Mouth Creamy Mac & Cheese

by Utokia Langley
5 Cheese Mac and Cheese | ShesGotFlavor

Macaroni and Cheese is most affectionately known as Mac & Cheese or the soul of comfort food!  There are so many different ways to cook Mac & Cheese.  You can bake it, cook it on the stove top, fry it and the list goes on and on.  You can also interchange the cheese you use based on your taste buds and add things like lobster and bacon.  I even have a couple variations on my blog like this one!  The Mac & Cheese recipe in this post is one of my favorite because it is my potluck staple, the one that everyone loves.  It is just down home creamy ooey gooey good!  You have to play around with Mac & Cheese to find “your” perfect one!  Try this one out for size, it just might be the right one for you too!  Oh and by the way my Crispy Curry Fried Chicken would partner perfectly with this Mac & Cheese!

Oh Yeah!!!!!5 Cheese Melt in your Mouth Creamy Mac & Cheese | ShesGotFlavor
Can you feel the cheese love?!?!5 Cheese Melt in your Mouth Creamy Mac & Cheese | ShesGotFlavor
What a beautiful bite!5 Cheese Melt in your Mouth Creamy Mac & Cheese | ShesGotFlavor



1 box of elbow pasta (plus ingredients on back of box)
2 tbsp. extra virgin olive oil
2 tbsp. granulated garlic
1 stick unsalted butter (room temperature, plus 1-2 tsp to butter the baking dish)
¼ cup all-purpose flour
1 8oz. mascarpone cheese or cream cheese
1 cup heavy whipping cream
2 cups half and half
2 tbsp. Dijon mustard
2 tsp. nutmeg
1 bag shredded Mexican Blend Cheese (mild cheddar, monterey jack, queso quesadilla and asadero)
2 tbsp. granulated sugar
2-3 tbsp. Sea Salt (plus 2 tbsp. for elbow pasta)
1-2 Ground black Pepper (plus 1 tbsp. for elbow pasta)


  1. Preheat oven to 400
  2. Cook elbow pasta as directed on back of box
  3. After pasta is cooked and drained, add pasta to a bowl and add extra virgin olive oil, granulated sugar, granulated garlic, sea salt, ground pepper and fold together
  4. Lightly butter a baking dish, add seasoned pasta to buttered baking dish (taste and add more seasoning to desired taste)
  5. In sauce pan melt unsalted butter over medium heat (I used the same pan I used to make the pasta for faster cleanup), once butter is melted add flour and whisk to combine (it will be a bit thick), then add mascarpone or cream cheese, heavy whipping cream, half and half, mustard and nutmeg and whisk until fully incorporated, cream cheese is melted and mixture is bubbly, then add mixture to baking dish and fold together with seasoned pasta until fully incorporated
  6. Add more cheese to top and place in oven on 400 degrees uncovered for 20 – 25 minutes or until cheese is melted and bubbly (* for extra cheesy add some extra mild cheddar to the mixture and on top)

Utokia ~
Sizzle Sizzle Baby


You may also like


Karen Petersen March 20, 2015 - 12:11 am

This looks super yummy! I like the addition of cream cheese. I think I need to make this soon 🙂
Cute video too! You are a natural 🙂

utokia March 20, 2015 - 8:08 am

Thank you Karen, hope you enjoy

Tonya June 25, 2015 - 6:00 am

Oooey-Gooey! Just the way my kids like it!

charlene March 10, 2016 - 10:41 pm

Ok I tried this recipe exactly but once fully made, was way to much salt, pepper, garlic, were the measurements wrong?

utokia March 20, 2016 - 4:04 pm

Hello Charlene, it may have too much seasoning for your taste buds just pull back on some of the seasoning, remember not everyone shares the same tastes buds so sometimes you have to do what works for you, try again and taste as you go, it really is great mac and cheese, you just have to make it your own, you have the foundation

Lucy Liberatore June 25, 2019 - 4:54 am

I watched your video aking your to die for Mac and Cheese , Its the recipe I am following exactly as you baked the Mac & Cheese , However, when I went to your site http://www.shesgotflavor.com , I am unable to find your exact recipe for the Mac and Cheese with the crunchy mixture of topping , you used a stick of butter melted with a bag of crushed garlic and cheese , which you sprinkled over the Mac & cheese followed by several handful of shredded grated cheddar. th en you baked it for 15 or 20 minutes till all the cheese melted, you tasted it and the yummy sounds you made while testing the finished Mac & Cheese is what made me want to make this recipe that same hour, however , the one recipe I do see on your site is not the one I watched you make but a 5 cheese Baked Mac & Cheese. How can I get the exact amounts of ingredients you used in making the Mac & Cheese I so want to make today for dinner with my Suthern Frid Chicken. Lucy Libby


Leave a Comment